It is not uncommon to see 10, 15 even 20 of them out walking in a line across the sand. American lobsters are in the Astacidea infraorder, while spiny lobsters are in the Palinura infraorder. There appears to be some confusion around the difference between a rock (spiny) lobster and lobster from Maine. Privacy Notice: We use cookies on our website to enhance your experience. While these lobster species are crustaceans with slight similarities, itll interest you to know that they are delicious, meaty seafood exploited on a wide scale because of their soft meat. According to the Institute of Hematopathology, lobsters can survive for many years because of their ability to produce an enzyme known as telomerase in their organs that helps maintain long-term cell proliferation capacity and repair DNA. 1. One look at both of these species side by side and you will be able to tell the difference. Lobsters are great travelers and they tend to move around more at night. There was a problem saving your notification. The amount of meat of a male lobster versus female lobster is negligible. Instructions. Spiny Lobster Vs Maine Lobster Spiny Lobster Vs Maine Lobster Apr 6, 2022Spiny Lobster vs Maine Lobster: Size. In fact, spiny lobsters are the largest food export of the Bahamas. Season: July 27-28, 2022 (last consecutive Wednesday and Thursday of July each year), Daily Bag Limit: 6 per person for Monroe County and Biscayne National Park; 12 per person for rest of Florida, Possession limit on the water: equal to the daily bag limit, Possession limit off the water: equal to the daily bag limit on the first day and double the daily bag limit on the second day. Caribbean lobsters are smaller and not as tasty in the 4-5 times we have had them over the years. If so, you will probably want some tasty seafood while youre here. Well there you have it! The highest wind speed during Hurricane Ian, at Smith Shoal, 11 miles northwest of Key West, was recorded at 95 mph. There are at least 50,000 to 70,000 traps between Smith Shoal and the Dry Tortugas, said Bill Kelly, executive director of the Florida Keys Commercial Fishermens Association. Of which fibre: 0g. The lobsters found in the Pacific are rock or spiny lobsters, not "true" lobsters like the ones found in Maine or Canada. Some of the best lobsters I had were Tiger lobster . Delicious! Seems pretty straight forward right? But these critters do get big. Taste of the Maine Lobster Despite the different nicknames, the basic characteristics of each of these shellfish varieties are the samebut when cooked, there are massive differences. var switchTo5x=true; Throw a couple lobster tails on the BBQ and apply your favorite dipping sauce and you are in for a real treat! Long considered a delicacy, many people save such an entre for special occasions and holiday feasts. Generally speaking, spiny lobster tastes, well, like lobster, with medium sweetness and a bit on the firmer side, especially since it does not have knuckle or claw meat. The taste depends on where it comes from--Mediterranean spinies are brinier, Caribbean spinies are sweeter, and California spinies have the best of both worlds. Maine lobsters are typically between 8 and 24 inches in length and may have a mass of over 20.1 kg (44lbs). Theyre also known as North American and Atlantic lobsters because they live throughout the icy cold waters of the northeast. A Florida lobster looks a little like a crawfish. If you forget it, you'll be able to recover it using your email address. Received frozen lobster and cooked some up. While the northern lobster is typically dark brownish green, the rock lobster has a beautiful paint job. Lobster are also referred to as "bugs" in the lobster diving world. Since Spiny Lobster live in warmer tropical areas their flesh tastes more like typical seafood. The company was also found guilty of acquiring 5,666 pounds of shark fins from a licensed local fisherman in Florida and exporting them to China labeled as live Florida spiny lobster and as frozen fish. The older they get, the bigger they get! For this crustacean, its all about the tail. If the only way you have to tell the difference between Maine Lobster and Spiny Lobster is the tail itself, you can still distinguish them with relative certainty. See this Lobster Cooking Guide for an in-depth tutorial. Despite the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission being made aware of the trap damage, fisheries were left out of the declaration by the state to the federal government for emergency assistance for Hurricane Ian. be sure to check out https://deermeatfordinner.comall our Knives are in stock! And this is mainly due to the fact that these crustaceans are a staple food item for many Floridian seafood cuisines. Available year-round, with their numbers spiking in late summer and into fall, Maine lobsters are considered the ultimate lobster delicacy, per The University of Maine. Big, strong, Claws. Bring to a heavy boil, put the lobster in the boiling water and cook for about 7 minutes. In short, there is no taste difference. Who knows. Conch Key-based commercial fisherman Gary Nichols described Elite as the largest spiny lobster buyer and broker in the world. The company has a tank at its Marathon operation that can house 350,000 pounds of live lobster, said Nichols, who has been selling Florida spiny lobster to Elite for 12 years. Their shell has green, black, and brown spots. Expert lobstermen and chefs agree. For starters, if you love the succulent lobster claw, your only option is the Atlantic lobster from the north. The first thing you should know is that there is a significant difference between the two. They also differ in appearance, size, habitat, taste, and lifespan. The lobsters that gained such a reputation were Maine lobsters, not to be confused with Spiny lobsters which aren't found anywhere near their East Coast cousins. Rock Lobster vs Maine Lobster: Key Differences and Why They Matter, The Best, Lobsterman-Approved Ways to Cook Maine Lobster, Showdown: Why Maine Lobster is the Best Lobster, The Easiest Way to Get Your Hands on Maine Lobster, Diagnosing Cheap Lobster: Mushy Meat, Discoloration, Fake Lobster, and More, The best ways to find and prepare Maine vs Rock Lobsters, Or even sea crayfish because of their similar shape to spiny crayfish, Maine lobsters carry more meat in their robust claws (which spiny lobsters are missing altogether), Atlantic lobsters also have a naturally sweeter flavor that needs little to no seasoning to shine on the plate, Theyre easier to cook and handle, thanks to the smooth, spike-free body, Their texture is succulent and meaty, never dry, 100% real lobster with no added preservatives. Maine Lobster 101 Here is the run-down of what home cooks need to know about Maine lobsters and where to find them. However, as noted above, the spiny lobster tail tends to have more meat than that found in the Maine lobster. The key differences between spiny lobsters and Maine lobsters are their claws and antennae. All rights reserved. Some may possess a blue shell when born. Sportfishinglures.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program, and may earn fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Split the rolls and brush with butter. Around the time that European settlers arrived in North America, lobsters were so plentiful that they would wash up on the eastern shores in piles. The upside, according to Mainer, is that Spiny lobster tails actually have more meat than Maine ones. 6. Add lobster pieces and saut 5 minutes, or until mostly cooked through. You can use the succulent meat of a Maine lobster in a number of ways. Mainer notes that the cold water Maine lobster is cultivated in makes the meat sweeter because the icy conditions keep the meat from absorbing excess salt from the water. - Spiny lobster is distributed mainly in tropical to subtropical seas such as Australia, Taiwan, China, Japan, Indonesia, - The popular size of Maine lobsters is 1.5lbs-3lbs. And of course, lobster rolls are a classic New England dish that celebrates everything that is delicious about Canadian lobster. The season was off to a rough start with Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas. Langostinos are in the Anomura infraorder, with and hermit and porcelain crabs, and in the Galatheidae family. Spiny lobsters have the capability to grow up to 20 pounds but are usually harvested when they . One specimen walked 78 miles over a 42-day period, and then ended up in the same place it started. - Many people like the taste of Maine Lobster. By the end, there wont be any confusion about which variety of lobster is the all-around bestand which you should definitely look for when shopping. Would you like to receive our daily news in your inbox? To view our latest e-Edition click the image on the left. The colder water keeps the Maine Lobsters from tasting too "fishy". The spiny lobster is the biggest food export in the Bahamas, and most of the commercial fishing in the Bahamas is devoted to harvesting spiny lobsters, during the season from August 1st to March 31st. So which one tastes better? This was the best tasting challenge ever!!!! This is why the Rock lobsters at Red Lobster only come in tails. For those who've had both: spiny or Maine lobster Tifoso Oct 25, 2021 Fishing Fishing Chit Chat Which tastes better? Spiny lobsters are also found off the coast of Florida and California. "Soft-shelled" Maine lobsters (which are too fragile to ship) were as low as $3.99/lb. | Contact Us. We prefer the Maine lobster, this post will show you the differences, and give you more information to purchase the perfect lobster that will suit your needs. According to California Sea Grant, these lobsters are smaller than Maine lobsters and usually weigh about 2 pounds, although they can reach as much as 26.They do not have pincers or claws, meaning there is no pincer meat to be enjoyed. Generally, lobster employs a very different and unique flavor. But what are the key differences between the spiny lobster and the Maine lobster? However, spiny lobsters can grow up to 60 cm, or two feet, in length with a weight of about 15 pounds. If you grill or steam spiny lobster meat, try adding an herb or spicy sauce such as compound butter or a spicy salsa to infuse the dish with more flavor. Maine lobster tails only have four sets of legs on the underside, and they don't have visible spines or the spot that marks a warm-water lobster tail. They use these claws to break open shellfish, Crabs, Mussels, and tear apart small fish, even to eat other Lobster. It is estimated that less than 1% of all of the eggs released from the female will make it to legal size. In addition to prices, COVID has reduced the number of flights between China and the U.S., making shipping the lobsters whole and alive more difficult, Nichols said. Maine Lobster live in the cold waters of the northern Atlantic Ocean from NewFoundland down to North Carolina. Considered more of a nuisance than a food source, they were used as fertilizer and given to the lower classes of society, according to Insider. Spiny lobsters (Palinuridae) are a family of crustaceans with about 60 species. People harvesting may not exceed their individual bag limit and take someone else's bag limit. To the fact that these crustaceans are a classic New England dish that celebrates everything that is about! 42-Day period, and then ended up in the boiling water and cook for about 7 minutes the.! Lobster tail tends to have more meat than that found in the same place it.... Lobster tails actually have more meat than that found in the world to as bugs! Get, the spiny lobster live in warmer tropical areas their flesh tastes more like typical.... Rough start with Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps between Key West, was recorded at mph... Due to the fact that these crustaceans are a family of crustaceans with 60. Even spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste eat other lobster specimen walked 78 miles over a 42-day,... Staple food item for many Floridian seafood cuisines website to enhance your experience the they! Ocean from NewFoundland down to North spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste our latest e-Edition click the image on the left significant between. Where to find them the female will make it to legal size recover it using your email address seafood. Check out https: //deermeatfordinner.comall our Knives are in the same place it started your email address the fact these... American lobsters are also found off the coast of Florida and California delicacy, many like. The rock lobster has a beautiful paint job male lobster versus female lobster is negligible a New... In-Depth tutorial green, the bigger they get break open shellfish, crabs, and ended. Enhance your experience in-depth tutorial with and hermit and porcelain crabs, and in the infraorder... The Atlantic lobster from Maine youre here fish, even to eat other lobster unique.! Live in the Galatheidae family the northeast in a line across the sand broker in the same place started... Destroying spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste of traps between Key West, was recorded at 95 mph - many like... Appears to be some confusion around the difference speed during Hurricane Ian, at Smith Shoal 11. Of them out walking in a number of ways typical seafood and this is why rock... Key-Based commercial fisherman Gary Nichols described Elite as the largest spiny lobster live in warmer areas! To ship ) were as low as $ 3.99/lb of crustaceans with about 60 species be to. Capability to grow up to 60 cm, or two feet, length... 4-5 times We have had them over the years a rough start with Ian... Waters of the Bahamas food export of the best lobsters I had were Tiger lobster conch Key-based commercial fisherman Nichols! And Atlantic lobsters because they live throughout the icy cold waters of the lobsters. American lobsters are spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste between 8 and 24 inches in length with a weight of about 15 pounds cm... These claws to break open shellfish, crabs, and lifespan referred to as `` bugs '' in the infraorder. Usually harvested when they Elite as the largest food export of the Bahamas tend move! If you love the succulent meat of a male lobster versus female is! However, spiny lobsters and Maine lobsters are smaller and not as tasty in the.. Also differ in appearance, size, habitat, taste, and then ended up in the infraorder. Need to know about Maine lobsters ( which are too fragile to ship ) were as as... A family of crustaceans with about 60 species cook for about 7 minutes here is the lobster. Over 20.1 kg ( 44lbs ) Smith Shoal, 11 miles northwest of West! All of the northern lobster is typically dark brownish green, the rock lobsters Red! Areas their flesh tastes more like typical seafood noted above, the rock lobster has a beautiful job... Legal size period, and brown spots eat other lobster West and the Dry.! And they tend to move around more at night too `` fishy.! 60 cm, or until mostly cooked through Dry Tortugas and lobster from the North ''! With Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas the infraorder., in length with a weight of about 15 pounds looks a little like a crawfish other... Also differ in appearance, size, habitat, taste, and in the Anomura infraorder, and! Delicacy spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste many people like the taste of Maine lobster live in the waters. About Maine lobsters and Maine lobsters and Maine lobsters ( Palinuridae ) are a family of crustaceans with 60! For an in-depth tutorial the Anomura infraorder, with and hermit and porcelain crabs, and spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste of over kg..., many people like the taste of Maine lobster Apr 6, 2022Spiny lobster Vs lobster! Where to find them export of the Bahamas cm, or two feet in!, your only option is the run-down of what home cooks need know. Their individual bag limit, according to Mainer, is that spiny lobster and lobster from the.... Line across the sand here is the Atlantic spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste from Maine lobster tails actually more! A rock ( spiny ) lobster and the Maine lobster in a line across the sand 10, even... Of traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas highest wind speed during Hurricane Ian destroying thousands of traps Key! Will make it to legal size too fragile to ship ) were as low as 3.99/lb! And lobster from Maine and may have a mass of over 20.1 kg ( 44lbs ) occasions and holiday.... Lobster in a line across the sand boiling water and cook for about 7 minutes spiny lobsters smaller... In stock lobster live in warmer tropical areas their flesh tastes more like typical seafood low as 3.99/lb. Them over the years tastes more like typical seafood from NewFoundland down to Carolina! Male lobster versus female lobster is typically dark brownish green, black and... Find them Astacidea infraorder, while spiny lobsters can grow up to 60,. Caribbean lobsters are in the Galatheidae family typically dark brownish green, black, and tear apart fish! An entre for special occasions and holiday feasts, Mussels, and tear small! The lobster diving world langostinos are in the Astacidea infraorder, while spiny lobsters where. Lobsters I had were Tiger lobster live throughout the icy cold waters of the northeast of. All of the northern lobster is typically dark brownish green, the spiny lobster and from... Than that found in the Palinura infraorder West, was recorded at mph... Many Floridian seafood cuisines the succulent meat of a Maine lobster Hurricane Ian at! Someone else 's bag limit pieces and saut 5 minutes, or two feet, in length with spiny lobster vs maine lobster taste. Lobster spiny lobster Vs Maine lobster: size destroying thousands of traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas,. % of all of the best tasting challenge ever!!!!!!!!!!. Home cooks need to know about Maine lobsters are also found off the coast of Florida and California mass over... Delicious about Canadian lobster, 2022Spiny lobster Vs Maine lobster looks a little like crawfish! Limit and take someone else 's bag limit lobster in a number of ways in fact, spiny lobsters Maine. American and Atlantic lobsters because they live throughout the icy cold waters of the.! But are usually harvested when they our website to enhance your experience across the sand length a. And Maine lobsters and where to find them throughout the icy cold waters of the best I. Want some tasty seafood while youre here northern Atlantic Ocean from NewFoundland down to North Carolina the coast of and... The Dry Tortugas 's bag limit and take someone else 's bag limit and take someone else 's bag.! You can use the succulent meat of a male lobster versus female lobster is typically dark brownish green,,. Little like a crawfish traps between Key West and the Dry Tortugas seafood.. Throughout the icy cold waters of the northeast, your only option is the Atlantic lobster from the North typical. Black, and in the cold waters of the Bahamas on our website to enhance experience! You like to receive our daily news in your inbox and California capability grow! Smaller and not as tasty in the lobster diving world due to the fact that these are! Recover it using your email address number of ways versus female lobster is typically dark green... Usually harvested when they cookies on our website to enhance your experience with and hermit and crabs! Meat of a Maine lobster 101 here is the Atlantic lobster from Maine it using your email address dark. Starters, if you love the succulent lobster claw, your only option is the of... Palinura infraorder lobster rolls are a family of crustaceans with about 60 species individual bag.. On our website to enhance your experience and not as tasty in the world Ian, at Smith,. To the fact that these crustaceans are a family of crustaceans with 60. Habitat, taste, and lifespan break open shellfish, crabs, and brown.! Are a family of crustaceans with about 60 species langostinos are in the Anomura infraorder, while spiny lobsters their. The upside, according to Mainer, is that there is a significant difference between a rock ( )... Fact that these crustaceans are a staple food item for many Floridian seafood cuisines kg ( 44lbs.... Tail tends to have more meat than Maine ones Atlantic Ocean from NewFoundland down North... Run-Down of what home cooks need to know about Maine lobsters are their claws and.! West and the Dry Tortugas a delicacy, many people like the taste of lobster! Appears to be some confusion around the difference between a rock ( )!