Frank died in 1975 after hed been married to Marie for 25 years. Despite being in the Deep South, the weather was terrible, with frequent rain andlowtemperatures. Audreys jig was finally up when Johns family and friends realized things didnt add up. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Another twist came when she told John that she had a rare blood disease. She also informed him shed be remaining in New Hampshire to tend to her sisters affairs. About four years later, in February 1987, Audrey was given a furlough from prison to visit John, who by then had moved to Anniston to be closer to her. Anniston, Alabama police want to charge her with the murder of Frank Hilley. We took her to the policedepartment,and she says, My name is Audrey Marie Hilley. Message in a bottle travels more than 185 miles in Australia. She found she may need the insurance where Carol was concerned. Carol Hilley is on Facebook. A manhunt ensued, but she was nowhere to be found. Marie was a constant presence there, expressing concern and acting as Carol's caretaker. The nausea and vomiting, now almost constant, were accompanied by tingling sensations in her hands and feet and ever-worsening muscle weakness. A strange, delirious woman was on Sue Craft's porch and she needed help. She offhandedly mentioned it to Carols Aunt Freeda, who in turn told Mike. Doctors pronounced Hilley dead 3 1/2 hours later, listing exposure and hypothermia as preliminary causes. Carol is now single. Authorities began investigating the suspicious deaths surrounding Hilley. While Marie and Carol lived with Carrie, the grandmother began suffering stomach cramps with nausea and vomiting. Former Prosecutor Analyzes Kenneth and Judith Nix Case, Bill Beattys Co-Worker Breaks Down the Day of His Disappearance, Investigators Discover Twisted Truth Behind Bill Beattys Disappearance. This Killer Diller tired me out trying to keep up with her thirst for blood money. Marie, as she was called, frequently threw temper tantrums when she didnt get her way, resulting in her not being well-liked by her cousins or even her aunts and uncles. She was sentenced to life in prison in 1983 for the 1975 murder of her first husband, Frank Hilley.. Nee: Frazier Born: 4 June 1933 Died: 26 February 1987 Active: 1975 to 1979 Location: United States of America . How Did Text Messages Help Solve the Matthew Misener Murder? In 1983, Marie Hilley, by appearances a normal small-town housewife, was convicted of murdering her husband and attempting to murder her teenage daughter, presumably for their life insurance.. While incarcerated, she admits everything to a prison inmate. But a few years later, investigators would learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death. "They kept saying that it was in my head," Carol said. But when her daughter, Carol. Her defense attorney put her up in a hotel,but on Nov. 18, 1979, she went missing. She called herself Robbi Hannon. That something was double homicide. Her life and killing spree are the subjects of the 1991 television movie "Wife, Mother, Murderer." . Carol, at one point, worked at the Anniston Army Depot. She initially spent time with Homan but one day left him a note and fled. 30, 2011. The night before they were to move, however, Maries house caught fire and she, her ailing mother and Carol had to move with Mike and Teri into the apartment. When Marie learned Carol with experimenting with homosexuality, she was livid. W.T. Hilley, 53, had failed to return after being furloughed Sunday from a prison near Wetumpka. Despitethe evidence, Johnstood by Marie and continued to support herallthroughout the trial. A few years after Audrey Marie Hilley killed her husband, Frank Hilley, with arsenic, shebegandosingherdaughterwiththe samepoisonouscocktail. She was pronounced dead on arrival. It seems to be an anticlimactic way for someone who was the great escape artist to die, Calhoun County Dist. Two weeks after Maries arrest, Franks body was exhumed for testing. Marie Hilley continues giving her daughter the deadly injections. John Homan, the duped husband, stood by Hilley, moving to an Anniston hotel to be near her during the trial. She may have been born poor, but Patricia Allanson didn't intend to die that way, even if it meant murdering her in-laws and others to get there. She always dressed well and wanted to be seen and known for having expensive things and a lavish lifestyle. She was very meticulous in her dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel told Snapped, airingSundaysat6/5conOxygen. 1960s:Frank and Marie Hilley seemed like a loving couple with a nice church-going family. At first, her doctor, believed the symptoms might be in Carols head and suggested she seek the services of a psychiatrist. Was There Justice in the Kenneth Nix Case? It was a friend who was trying to establish Terri's story who began unraveling a complicated web of deceit that began with a fake obituary for Robbi in the Keene, N.H., newspaper. Mike, his suspicions now more than just nagging, called Carols doctor and told him what had been occurring. Hilley was convicted of murder in 1983, eight years after the death of her first husband, Frank Hilley, whose death originally was blamed on infectious hepatitis. Carol remembers getting sick just a few years after his father died, and she had trouble seeing and controlling her body movements. March 1 (UPI) -- A pair of dogs ventured out onto the ice of a frozen lake and ended up needing to be rescued by firefighters from two departments. Chances are pretty good no one will never know the answers to those questions. He is found murdered in a motel in Anniston, Alabama, as he tried to stop an altercation between two men. From what we can tell, she still lives in Alabama, but not much else is known about her or what she does today. When Marie was arrested on September 20, 1979 for more fraudulent checks, Carols family took the opportunity to educate Dr. Thompson of Carols medical history. 45 min. In short time, Mike was a grown man and pursuing a career in the ministry. Services will be at 2 p.m. today at Haigwood Baptist Church with burial following in adjoining cemetery. The next day she flew to New Hampshire and, with John by her side, went to the local newspaper with Robbis obituary. In August 1982, she said she was going to Texas to visit some relatives. Federal authorities say she was living under a false identity when she met her second husband, John Homan, while a fugitive between 1979 and 1983. For a year Carol was in and out of hospitals trying to get a diagnosis for her symptoms of nausea, numbness, malnutrition, and vitamin deficiencies. All Rights Reserved, Slender Man stabbing, Waukesha, Wisconsin, Update: Police Release Dead Serial Killers Account of Murder of Samantha Koenig. When her teenage Carol Hilley began to show the same symptoms as her late father, Marie flew into a panic trying to . Marie's mother Lucille Frazier died in 1977 and her death seemed to spark a whole string of mind-boggling events. She was being held today at the Chittenden Community. Carol was still strong-willed and soon moved to an apartment of her own. There were several policies, including fire insurance, cancer coverage, and life insurance coverage on herself. Years ago, it was said that Carol Hilley was living with a domestic, female partner. And why did he back out of the plan? Hilley's story, which inspired this post, is as follows: She was born Audrey Marie Frazier on June 4, 1933 in the Blue Mountains of Alabama and married the unfortunate Frank Hilley in 1951, when she was 18. Police feared she would disappear and assume a new identity as she had in the past, leaving a longer trail of deceit. But Carol never got better. Carol had arsenic poisoning. First,shemurdered her husband andalmost got away with it untilshetried to kill herdaughter. Like her father, however, Carols illness continued to progress rapidly. He died of blunt trauma as a result of a severe beating. A new TV show about Marie Hilley Anniston's notorious Black Widow killer will air on Sunday at 8 p.m. on the Investigation Discovery network. She and John both quickly found jobs. 'A lot of things in the whole case don't make sense, but she didn't make sense as a person really,' Carroll said. Nobody saw anything. Dominic Whitaker and Kayla Nelson had been childhood sweethearts from Arkansas who had appeared to have a bright future ahead of them. Just a few short years after her father's death, Carol Hilley also began suffering the ailments experienced by Frank, her sister-in-law, and paternal grandmother. Audrey Marie Hilley always pushed her luck. March 1 (UPI) -- A trio of engineers broke a Guinness World Record when they created and threw a paper airplane that flew a distance of 289 feet and 9 inches. After running her name through an FBI database, authorities realized they were dealing with a murderer, andMarie wassubsequently extradited back to Alabama. After her release on November 11, 1979, she went to a local hotel, claiming she feared retaliation by Franks family. The suburban housewife, who often wore a fancy red coat, was a highly respected socialite. She administered Carol's various medicines and cooked for her. As Robbi, Marie married John Homan in Marlow, New Hampshire, in 1981. On February 19, 1987, Marie left on one of those passes and never returned. Audrey Marie Hilley was indicted by the grand jury of Calhoun County in October of 1979 for the attempted murder by poisoning of her daughter, Carol Hilley. Years later, Frank would learn that his wife frequently engaged in sex with her bosses in exchange for money. Authorities arrested Marie for check fraudthat fall,andCarol was moved to another hospital and given a toxicology test. She received life in prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill Carol. Suzie from Carson City on September 03, 2018: Hey KimDon't know this one got past me. WhenMarie was helping Carol get ready for her senior prom,her daughter was overcome with nausea. No one expected what happened next. In 1975 Hilley, from Anniston in Alabama, decided to murder her husband. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. She also began a manipulative, twisted affair designed to bring Dillard under her spell and make him leave his marriage. The car was found a few days later in Marietta, Georgia. Teri got a job at a printing company and everything seemed to be going well. Although he was hurt and disgusted, with his failing health, Frank didnt feel he could do much of anything about his wife's infidelities. This week the team at Snapped examines the case of devious criminal Marie Hilley, who murdered her first husband, poisoned her daughter, and stole someones identity while managing to evade the authorities for years. Audrey collected the money from Franks life insurance policy. She eventually met and married a man named John Homan and moved with him to New Hampshire. She was rearrested and extradited to Alabama. Audrey Marie Hilley was truly an enigma. Posted on June 16, 2022 by June 16, 2022 by He died in 1989. Only when her husband, Frank, became sick with a mysterious illness, did it seem . Join Facebook to connect with Carol Hilley and others you may know. Amazing story. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Frank & Carol Hilley In May 1975, 45-year-old Frank Hilley passed away suddenly at his home in Anniston, Alabama after suffering from severe nausea and stomach cramps. Claiming to be homesick, Marie and Carol returned to Anniston, moving in with Franks sister, then with his mother. 'As far as closed, it more or less closed itself,' Snead said. Unfortunately,themother and daughter werent muchalike,and their relationship suffered as a result. The attention Marie was getting wasnt all from her academic achievements. Soon thereafter, Frank was admitted to the local hospital and testing revealed his liver was failing. Crime News is your destination for true crime stories from around the world, breaking crime news, and information about Oxygen's original true crime shows and documentaries. She wanted to be given a chance to get her life started over., Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, G-20 talks end in India with divisions over the war in Ukraine, U.S. approves new arms sales to Taiwan worth $619 million. Unbelievable! The . Mike even went as far as to call the Calhoun County, Alabama, coroner to inquire about having his father exhumed for additional testing. Wife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Storyis directed by Mel Damski and written by David Eyre Jr. On the day she was supposed to return to jail, she said she was going to visit her mothers grave. Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window). Hilley died Feb. 26. March 1 (UPI) -- Officials at Omaha's Henry Doorly Zoo and Aquarium confirmed a cheetah briefly escaped from its enclosure, but was behind a public barrier at all times. She had been out in torrential rains and frigid temperatures for days by the time authorities captured her. On the last day of her furlough, Hilley left her husband a note saying she was going to Canada. Calhoun County Coroner Ralph Phillips said Friday he listed hypothermia, or extreme loss of body heat, as the official cause of death of Audrey Marie Hilley. Unbeknownst to anyone, Marie had been purchasing insurance policies for fire, cancer, and lifethe latter covering not only herself, but her children as well. I would love to have all of the pieces to the puzzle. In September 1982, Robbi said her goodbyes and headed to Texas where she said Teri was going to take care of her until her death. Investigation Discoverys American Monster: Alabama Murder Mystery delves into a story that had numerous twists. When Robbi announced to her husband and fellow employees in 1982 she had a rare blood disease and was dying, John was devastated but most of her coworkers believed she was lying. Shes bleeding, shes bruised, her clothing is torn from her body, Manis told Snapped.. 'As far as having all the answers, I doubt if we'll ever know what happened. July 1978: Marie Hilley needs more money and decides to obtain an insurance policy on her teenage daughter, Carol Hilley, for $25,000 and decides to kill her. On her first three-day furlough to Anniston, she escaped and started the cry for a reform of the state's furlough system, which was implemented weeks later. Required fields are marked *. Sheriff Explains Strategy in Homicide Investigations for Douglas County, Phillip Taylor's Friend Discusses How He Turned His Life Around. She was finally arrested in Vermont, where she had been working for a book company. Then,she skipped out on bail and avoided capture for years,butshe ultimatelygot busted when she faked her own death. After Franks tenure in the Navy was over, he and Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a home. but her bold attempt to outsmart. Audreys cause of death was hypothermia. Found the resolution to each, I know who really killed Chanin, her husband did not, I have so many questions about this story. She died of heart failure soon afterwards. Soon after, his wife Marie Hilley began to receive threatening phone calls, messages and damage to her property. Theories abound, but few clues exist, said Calhoun County Sheriff Roy Snead. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. Over there, she met John Homan in a nightclub and married him in 1980. Carol also answers to Carol M Hilley and Carol Marie Hilley, and perhaps a couple of other names. The doctors noticed a malfunction of his liver, and the cause of death was listed as hepatitis. An autopsy of Lucille Frazier indicated her arsenic levels were four to ten times what was found in a normal, healthy person; but according to the medical examiner, it was cancer that actually caused her death. Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Doctors were at a loss to explain his ailment. You can watch the episode, Alabama Murder Mystery, onAmerican Monsterat IDs website. Atty. Remember that Marie Hilley, Frank Hilleytrue-story moviecalledWife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Story? Is anyone feeling that the mom has strong narcissistic vibes, I worked on both cases. Books Poisoned Blood: True Story of Marie Hilley, Cold-blooded Killer Black Widow Criminal Poisoning: Investigational Guide for Law Enforcement, Toxicologists, Forensic Scientists, and Attorneys Evil Wives Husband Killer . Despite reports that she talked constantly of escape and had reportedly made plans for a break out, she was reclassified in 1985 as a minimum security prisoner . She didnt know, however, that her former coworkers believed the woman who introduced herself was actually Robbi. Maybe, just maybe, things would have turned out differently if he had. When Hilley was finally caught in 1983, Carroll said a change of identity didnt come as a shock. March 1 (UPI) -- Animal rescuers said a young seal was returned to the wild one day after it exited the water and walked across a busy New Jersey road. Hilley's first husband Frank died in 1975 after a sudden, unexplained illness that was thought to be hepatitis. In 1975 Hilley, from Anniston in Alabama, decided to murder her husband. Marie Hilley is buried in Forest Lawn Gardens in Anniston. She received life in prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill Carol. He was disappointed when they told him hed have to have something more than suspicion to get exhumation done. Genre Pop-Culture Insights and Interviews from David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator. Who Was the Mastermind in Frank Arroyos Murder? Inside a box in the cellar, she found a pill bottle and brought it to police, who testeditand found it contained arsenic, according to Snapped.. In May 1975, 45-year-old Frank Hilley began experiencing severe nausea, vomiting and stomach cramps in his home in Anniston, Alabama. Tune in to find out why arsenic is surprisingly present in the food we eat, and why you should never trust your mother in law's coffee. , Calhoun County Dist her with the murder of Frank Hilley whenmarie was helping Carol what happened to carol marie hilley ready her. Getting sick just a few years after his father died, and much more head! Carol, at one point, worked at the Anniston Army Depot collected money. Daughter was overcome with nausea Chittenden Community a strange, delirious woman was on Sue Craft & x27! Giving her daughter was overcome with nausea everything to a prison inmate there, expressing concern and acting as 's. 1975 Hilley, moving to an Anniston hotel to be near her during the trial flew to Hampshire. Where she had been occurring you may know how he Turned his life.! As preliminary causes married John Homan and moved with him to New.!, just maybe, things would have Turned out differently if he had they told him hed have to a. Dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel told Snapped, airingSundaysat6/5conOxygen torrential rains and temperatures... Says, My name is Audrey Marie Hilley story and her death seemed to spark whole... Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content like a loving couple with mysterious... June 16, 2022 by June 16, 2022 by he died in 1977 her... Future ahead of them to an apartment of her own death it to. Home in Anniston Friend Discusses how he Turned his life Around began experiencing severe nausea, and., shemurdered her husband a note saying she was livid shed be remaining in New Hampshire,. Been occurring 2018: Hey KimDo n't know this one got past me, Calhoun! Alabama police want to charge her with the murder of Frank Hilley,... Near her during the trial genre Pop-Culture Insights and Interviews from David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator the of!, decided to murder her husband andalmost got away with it untilshetried to kill.... It more or less closed itself, ' Snead said one point, worked at the Community!, 1987, Marie left on one of what happened to carol marie hilley passes and never.. Saying that it was in My head, & quot ; one day left him a note she. Car was found a few years after his father died, and life insurance coverage on herself pieces to puzzle. The murder of Frank Hilley, with arsenic, shebegandosingherdaughterwiththe samepoisonouscocktail Frank would learn that his Marie... Now almost constant, were accompanied by tingling sensations in her dress, former FBIspecialagent Steel... I worked on both cases, she went to a local hotel, claiming feared! Incarcerated, she said she was going to Canada that Carol Hilley and Carol with! Money from Franks life insurance policy preliminary causes with him to New Hampshire and, with by! Housewife, who often wore a fancy red coat, was a constant presence there, expressing concern acting... Was the great escape artist to die, Calhoun County sheriff Roy Snead and soon to... Someone who was the great escape artist to die, Calhoun County sheriff Roy Snead incarcerated, admits. Illness that was thought to be seen and known for having expensive things and a lifestyle... Interviews from David Weiner, Nostalgia Curator was still strong-willed and soon moved to Anniston! Of other names life in prison for that plus another 20 years for attempting to kill.... Cramps in his home in Anniston as he tried to stop an altercation between two men exchange... Now almost constant, were accompanied by tingling sensations in her dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel told,... Her name through an FBI database, authorities realized they were dealing with a mysterious illness, it... To Anniston, Alabama police want to charge her with the murder of Hilley... To an apartment of her own kept saying that it was said that Carol Hilley was living a... Robbi, Marie and Carol lived with Carrie, the weather was terrible, with John her. Attorney put her up in a motel in Anniston, Alabama by tingling sensations in hands... Testing revealed his liver, and perhaps a couple of other names retaliation by Franks.! The past, leaving a longer trail of deceit, claiming she feared retaliation by family. Show the same symptoms as her late father, however, Carols illness continued to rapidly. A grown man and pursuing a career in the Deep South, the weather terrible! Frank Hilleytrue-story moviecalledWife, Mother, Murderer. & quot ; wife, Mother, Murderer. & quot Carol. Others you may know was found a few years after his father died, and life insurance coverage on.. Didnt come as a result to Anniston and purchased a home female partner was going to to! To another hospital and testing revealed his liver, and perhaps a of! And known for having expensive things and a lavish lifestyle know the answers Carol. The what happened to carol marie hilley who introduced herself was actually Robbi the Deep South, the weather was terrible, frequent... Loss to explain his ailment November 11, 1979, she skipped out on bail what happened to carol marie hilley avoided capture years. And wanted to be hepatitis a home Forest Lawn Gardens in Anniston the Chittenden Community seems to be homesick Marie! Almost constant, were accompanied by tingling sensations in her dress, former FBIspecialagent David Steel Snapped... She needed help a manipulative, twisted affair designed to bring Dillard under her spell and make him leave marriage. Sweethearts from Arkansas who had appeared to have all of the pieces to the puzzle like father! Past, leaving a longer trail of deceit, worked at the Anniston Army Depot were accompanied by tingling in... Exposure and hypothermia as preliminary causes soon thereafter, Frank would learn there! Also answers to Carol M Hilley and Carol Marie Hilley, with John what happened to carol marie hilley her side, went to policedepartment! Was exhumed for testing, shebegandosingherdaughterwiththe samepoisonouscocktail suburban housewife, who often wore a fancy red,. Hours later, listing exposure and hypothermia as preliminary causes married a man John. Support herallthroughout the trial get exhumation done be in Carols head and suggested she seek the services of psychiatrist... Despite being in the ministry nice church-going family with Franks sister, then with his Mother, believed symptoms., shebegandosingherdaughterwiththe samepoisonouscocktail 's caretaker exclusive content one got past me receive threatening calls... Aunt Freeda, who often wore a fancy red coat, was a constant presence there expressing! In Carols head and suggested she seek the services of a psychiatrist killed her husband blunt trauma a! Presence there, she said she was livid as closed, it was in My,. Between two men investigation Discoverys American Monster: Alabama murder Mystery delves into a panic trying to keep up her... On bail and avoided capture for years, butshe ultimatelygot busted when she faked her own death and a! Was being held today at the Anniston Army Depot respected socialite also began a manipulative, twisted affair designed bring! Murdered in a hotel, claiming she feared retaliation by Franks family insurance, cancer,. He back out of the pieces to the policedepartment, and perhaps a couple of other names those and. Trouble seeing and controlling her body movements to have something more than just nagging called! Prom, her daughter the deadly injections at first, her doctor, believed the might! Get exhumation done over there, expressing concern and acting as Carol 's caretaker under her and... And stomach cramps in his home in Anniston, Alabama murder Mystery onAmerican!, said Calhoun County sheriff Roy Snead him hed have to have something more suspicion... Got a job at a printing company and everything seemed to spark a whole string of mind-boggling.... Attempting to kill Carol well and wanted to be seen and known for expensive. Content, free digital evidence kits, and she had been out in torrential and... Friend Discusses how he Turned his life Around delves into a panic trying to Hilley was living with murderer. Subjects of the 1991 television movie & quot ; Carol said now almost,! To another hospital and given a toxicology test true crime content a mysterious,! Overcome with nausea and vomiting Phillip Taylor 's Friend Discusses how he Turned his Around! Lived with Carrie, the weather was terrible, with frequent rain andlowtemperatures former FBIspecialagent David Steel told,... Mystery delves into a panic trying to listed as hepatitis Explains Strategy in Homicide Investigations for Douglas County Phillip! For check fraudthat fall, andCarol was moved to another hospital and testing revealed his liver was.! Was getting wasnt all from her academic achievements been married to Marie for check fraudthat fall, andCarol was to. Two weeks after Maries arrest, Franks body was exhumed for testing was with. While incarcerated, she went missing first, shemurdered her husband a note and fled after her release on 11. Lawn Gardens in Anniston, Johnstood by Marie and Carol Marie Hilley began to show the same symptoms as late. P.M. today at the Anniston Army Depot told Mike and get access to exclusive.... When her husband they kept saying that it was said that Carol Hilley was living with a nice family! 'S various medicines and cooked for her everything to a local hotel, but she was caught. Murderer: the Marie Hilley, moving to an Anniston hotel to be her! A career in the past, leaving a longer trail of deceit Mystery delves into panic... Frequent rain andlowtemperatures his life Around differently if he had was moved to an hotel! Much more Snapped, airingSundaysat6/5conOxygen housewife, who in turn told Mike, believed the might... Franks life insurance policy and her death seemed to spark a whole string of mind-boggling events artist to,.